Engineering· · 4 min read
LoRaWAN, cellular, Wi-Fi or Matter: how we choose
There is no best radio. Each one moves a cost somewhere else: to a gateway, a SIM, the IT department or the battery. This is how we decide where it should go.
By Alessio Grespi, Founder & CEO
The first question we get about a new sensor is usually which radio it uses. Our answer is that it depends on the site, which sounds evasive until you see how different the options are.
A reading has to cross one hop between the device and the internet. LoRaWAN, cellular, Wi-Fi and Matter are four different answers to who owns that hop, and who fixes it when it stops.
Four questions first
Before we open a datasheet, we ask four things about the deployment:
- Is there mains power where the measurement is taken, or does the device run on a battery?
- How many devices will sit on one site: one, or two hundred?
- Does the device stay put, or does it move?
- Whose network are we allowed to touch?
The last one is the one people forget, and it rules out more options than the other three.
LoRaWAN: many battery sensors on one site
LoRaWAN sends small messages a long way on very little power. One gateway can cover a building, and a sensor that sends a reading every quarter of an hour can run on a battery for years. The gateway is ours and has its own connection out, so nothing touches the building's network.
What you pay with: a gateway on every site, which needs power and a route to the internet, and messages measured in bytes. In Europe, the rules for the band also cap how much airtime each device may use, typically to 1 per cent of the time. And when a gateway goes offline, every sensor behind it goes quiet at once.
Our water hygiene nodes use it, because one building can have dozens of measured points.
Cellular: one device per place, or anything that moves
A cellular device needs no gateway. It carries a SIM and talks to the nearest mast, so it suits a single cabinet in a field, a vehicle, or a tag on an animal. Adding a site adds nothing but devices.
What you pay with: a SIM and a data plan in every device, and more energy per message than LoRaWAN. The low-power variants, LTE-M and NB-IoT, close much of that gap, but in the UK their coverage still differs from one operator to the next, so we check the actual site before committing. We do not design anything new around 2G or 3G. The UK operators have retired 3G and have agreed that 2G will be gone by 2033 at the latest.
We are building our tracking tags on it, and it is what we would choose for a site with only one or two devices, where a gateway would never pay for itself.
Wi-Fi: mains power and a network you control
Wi-Fi is already in the building, carries far more data than LoRaWAN or low-power cellular, and costs nothing per message. For a mains-powered device on a network the customer runs, it can be the simplest choice.
What you pay with: power, passwords and permission. Wi-Fi drains a small battery quickly. The device needs the network's name and password, and it goes quiet the day someone changes them. And on someone else's site, getting a sensor approved for the corporate network can take longer than fitting it. That is why the products we build for contractors never touch the building's network.
Matter: when it has to work with everyone else's devices
Matter is not a radio. It is a standard for how smart-home devices describe themselves and talk to each other, and it runs on top of Wi-Fi or Thread. A Matter sensor can be set up from a phone and appear in whichever ecosystem the building already uses.
What you pay with: reach. Matter is built for devices talking to a controller in the same building, not for a fleet reporting to one place from two hundred sites. It suits homes and small buildings where a sensor has to sit alongside other makers' devices. On its own it does not get a reading into a record an auditor can open.
You are not choosing a radio. You are choosing who owns the hop in the middle, and who fixes it when it stops.
At a glance
LoRaWAN
Best for
Many battery sensors on one site
You pay with
A gateway on every site
Cellular
Best for
Single devices, and anything that moves
You pay with
A SIM in every device
Wi-Fi
Best for
Mains-powered devices on your own network
You pay with
Power, passwords and IT approval
Matter
Best for
Working alongside other makers' devices
You pay with
Reach beyond the building
Where we are today
Our water hygiene nodes are on LoRaWAN and in the field. Our tracking tags are cellular and in design. Wi-Fi and Matter are on our roadmap but not yet in the console. If your brief needs either, tell us: a built-to-spec job is how they get built.
Whichever radio carries it, a reading lands in the same place, tagged with where it was taken and which sensor it came from. The radio is a decision about the site, not about the data.